🔐 AES (Symmetric)
Same key for encryption and decryption
🔑 RSA (Asymmetric)
Public key encrypts, Private key decrypts
Help
What's the Difference Between AES and RSA?
AES (Symmetric Encryption):
- Uses one key for both encryption and decryption
- Very fast - can encrypt large amounts of data quickly
- Problem: How do you securely share the key?
- Like a physical lock - same key locks and unlocks
RSA (Asymmetric Encryption):
- Uses two keys - public key encrypts, private key decrypts
- Slow - 100-1000x slower than AES
- Solves key distribution - public key can be shared openly
- Like a mailbox - anyone can drop in mail (public), only owner retrieves (private)
When Should I Use Each Type?
Use AES when:
- Encrypting large files or databases
- You already have a secure way to share the key
- Speed is important
- Examples: Full disk encryption, encrypted backups, VPN connections
Use RSA when:
- Need to establish secure communication without prior key exchange
- Digital signatures (prove who sent a message)
- Encrypting small pieces of data (like AES keys)
- Examples: SSL/TLS handshake, email encryption (PGP), SSH keys
Use Both (Hybrid) when:
- Most real-world applications!
- RSA encrypts an AES key, then AES encrypts the actual data
- Examples: HTTPS, PGP email, secure messaging apps
How Does RSA Key Pair Work?
RSA uses two mathematically related keys:
- Public Key: Can be shared with anyone. Used to encrypt messages.
- Private Key: Must be kept secret. Used to decrypt messages.
Key properties:
- Messages encrypted with public key can ONLY be decrypted with private key
- It's computationally infeasible to derive private key from public key
- Keys are generated together as a matched pair
Digital Signatures (reverse):
- Sign with private key, verify with public key
- Proves the message came from the private key holder
Why is AES Faster Than RSA?
AES is fast because:
- Simple operations: XOR, bit shifts, table lookups
- Hardware acceleration available (AES-NI on modern CPUs)
- Optimized for bulk data processing
RSA is slow because:
- Requires modular exponentiation with huge numbers (2048+ bits)
- Mathematically complex operations
- Security depends on computational difficulty
Speed comparison:
- AES: Can encrypt ~1 GB/second on modern hardware
- RSA: Can encrypt ~1 MB/second (1000x slower!)
What are Key Sizes and Why Do They Matter?
AES Key Sizes:
- 128-bit: 2^128 possible keys - secure for most uses
- 192-bit: 2^192 possible keys - high security
- 256-bit: 2^256 possible keys - maximum security (used by governments)
RSA Key Sizes:
- 1024-bit: Deprecated - can be broken with sufficient resources
- 2048-bit: Current standard - secure until ~2030
- 4096-bit: High security - significantly slower but more secure
Important: Can't directly compare AES and RSA key sizes!
- RSA-2048 ≈ AES-112 in security strength
- RSA-3072 ≈ AES-128 in security strength
How Does HTTPS Use Both AES and RSA?
When you visit an HTTPS website:
- Handshake (RSA):
- Server sends its public key (in SSL certificate)
- Browser verifies certificate
- Browser generates random AES key
- Browser encrypts AES key with server's RSA public key
- Server decrypts AES key with its RSA private key
- Data Transfer (AES):
- All subsequent data encrypted with AES
- Fast encryption for images, HTML, etc.
- Both sides have the same AES key
Why hybrid? RSA solves key distribution, AES provides speed!
Can I Break These Encryptions?
AES-256:
- 2^256 possible keys
- Even if you tried 1 trillion keys per second, it would take longer than the age of the universe
- No known practical attacks
RSA-2048:
- Requires factoring a 2048-bit number into two primes
- Current records: 829-bit number factored (took years)
- 2048-bit is considered secure until at least 2030
- Quantum computers could break RSA (but not available yet)
Weak points are usually:
- Weak passwords (not the encryption itself)
- Implementation bugs
- Side-channel attacks (timing, power analysis)
- Social engineering (tricking users)